As the release of James Gunn’s Superman approaches on July 11, 2025, the film has sparked widespread curiosity, particularly regarding the sentiments of past actors who donned the iconic cape. This reboot, marking the debut of the DC Universe (DCU) under Gunn’s direction, features David Corenswet as a younger Clark Kent, replacing Henry Cavill, who portrayed the character in the DC Extended Universe (DCEU). With just over a month until its premiere, the reactions from Cavill and other notable Superman actors offer a mix of reflection, support, and anticipation, shedding light on the transition from legacy to innovation.
Henry Cavill, whose tenure as Superman began with Man of Steel in 2013, has maintained a diplomatic stance since his departure was announced in December 2022. After a brief return in Black Adam’s post-credits scene, Cavill expressed disappointment but accepted the shift, stating on Instagram, “The changing of the guard is something that happens. I respect that.” He acknowledged meeting with Gunn and Peter Safran, DC Studios’ co-CEOs, and expressed hope for future collaboration, though no specific projects have materialized. In a 2024 interview with GQ, Cavill reflected on his exit, noting, “It was a tough pill to swallow, but I understand the need for a fresh start. I wish David and James the best.” His comments suggest a willingness to move forward, though some fans interpret his silence on the 2025 film as lingering frustration over the abrupt end to his arc.
Christopher Reeve’s legacy, defined by his optimistic portrayal in the 1978 classic, looms large over Gunn’s reboot. While Reeve passed away in 2004, his son, Will Reeve, who appears as a cameo news reporter in the 2025 film, has shared insights. In a June 2025 ABC News segment, Will expressed pride, saying, “My dad would have loved seeing Superman evolve with this new energy. James Gunn’s focus on hope aligns with what Dad brought to the role.” This endorsement from Reeve’s family carries weight, suggesting a continuity of spirit despite the recasting. The inclusion of John Williams’ iconic score, reimagined for the film, further nods to Reeve’s era, a detail Will praised as “a beautiful tribute.”
George Reeves, the first to bring Superman to live-action television in the 1950s, left no direct comment, having passed in 1959. However, his niece, Berta Reeves, spoke to The Hollywood Reporter in May 2025, recalling, “Uncle George always said Superman was about inspiring people. If this new version does that, he’d be pleased.” Her remarks reflect a family perspective that values the character’s core ideals, which Gunn has emphasized as central to Corenswet’s portrayal.
Tom Welling, who played a youthful Clark Kent in Smallville (2001–2011), offered a supportive take during a convention panel in April 2025. “I think it’s great to see Superman reimagined for a new generation,” Welling said. “James Gunn’s approach seems to blend the fun we had on Smallville with a bigger scope. I’m excited to watch.” His comments highlight an appreciation for Gunn’s blend of humor and heart, drawing parallels to his own series’ tone.
Brandon Routh, who portrayed Superman in Superman Returns (2006), shared a more measured view. In a June 2025 podcast, he noted, “It’s a different direction, and that’s okay. I’d have loved to see Henry’s story continue, but David looks like he’s bringing something unique.” Routh’s experience with a film that bridged Reeve’s legacy and modern storytelling seems to inform his balanced perspective, acknowledging the reboot’s potential while mourning the lost DCEU narrative.
Fan and actor reactions on platforms like X mirror this diversity, with some praising Gunn’s vision as a hopeful reset, while others lament Cavill’s exit. Gunn himself has addressed the recasting, stating in 2023 that the film focuses on an earlier Superman, necessitating a younger actor. This decision, while logical for the story, has fueled debates about legacy, with Cavill’s supporters feeling his departure was mishandled by Warner Bros.
As Superman nears release, the film’s trailers—featuring Corenswet’s earnest Clark and a steamy Lois Lane romance with Rachel Brosnahan—hint at Gunn’s intent to honor past portrayals while forging a new path. The sentiments from Cavill, Reeve’s family, Welling, and Routh suggest a collective hope that this version respects Superman’s enduring legacy of hope and justice. With the DCU’s future hinging on this film, their words underscore a pivotal moment, blending nostalgia with anticipation for what lies ahead.
