In the world of professional cycling, few debates stir as much passion as the comparison between the Giro d’Italia and the Tour de France. Recently, a former Italian professional cyclist reignited this age-old rivalry by claiming, “The Giro d’Italia is much more exciting than the Tour de France.” According to him, the growing dominance of Slovenian superstar Tadej Pogačar has made the Tour de France more predictable, while the Giro continues to deliver drama and surprises.
Tadej Pogačar, who recently secured another commanding Tour de France victory, has been a dominant force in the peloton. His superior climbing, time-trial skills, and relentless tactics have left many of his rivals struggling to keep up. While his brilliance is undeniable, some argue that his supremacy has removed much of the suspense traditionally associated with the Tour. Stages that once hung in the balance are now often seen as formalities.
By contrast, the Giro d’Italia—Italy’s premier stage race—still thrives on uncertainty. Harsh weather in the Alps, unpredictable mountain stages, and grueling climbs like the Passo dello Stelvio or Monte Zoncolan regularly shake up the general classification. Riders face daily challenges that make it nearly impossible to predict a clear winner until the final stages. This year’s Giro, for instance, saw multiple lead changes and dramatic moments, keeping fans engaged from start to finish.
The former pro cyclist also emphasized the Giro’s deeper cultural connection to the Italian landscape and cycling heritage. “The Giro is not just a race—it’s a journey through Italy’s soul,” he said. From coastal roads in Liguria to snow-capped Dolomite passes, the Giro offers a visual spectacle that enhances the emotional and sporting drama.
While some cycling fans remain loyal to the grandeur and prestige of the Tour de France, others are beginning to agree with the Italian’s perspective. The Giro’s unpredictability, scenic routes, and fiercely contested stages arguably offer a purer form of racing.
In the end, both races have their unique allure. But as Tadej Pogačar continues to dominate July, more eyes may turn to Italy in May for the kind of suspense and excitement that only the Giro d’Italia seems able to deliver.
