As anticipation builds for James Gunn’s Superman: Legacy (2025), online forums have been flooded with discussions—and not all of them flattering. One recurring point of contention revolves around the updated yet retro-inspired costume design, particularly the inclusion of the classic red trunks. Dubbed “Superman’s pants” by fans, the iconic garment has sparked a storm of negative comments, with many criticizing it as an outdated choice that fails to resonate with modern audiences.
The debate stems from the decision to embrace Superman’s original look from the comic books, a nod to the character’s storied history. However, fans who grew accustomed to Henry Cavill’s sleek and contemporary costume in Man of Steel have expressed disappointment. Cavill’s streamlined design, which omitted the red trunks, was praised for its bold reimagining of Superman’s aesthetic, reflecting a modernized vision of the hero.
In contrast, Corenswet’s version—complete with the blue suit, red cape, and prominently featured red briefs—has been labeled as a step backward by critics online. Forums like Reddit and Twitter are rife with comments ranging from sarcastic quips about “Superman’s underwear” to more serious critiques about the costume design failing to convey the gravitas of the character.
Supporters of the classic look argue that the trunks are an integral part of Superman’s legacy, symbolizing his roots in the Golden Age of comics. James Gunn, known for his deep appreciation of comic book history, appears to have leaned into this sentiment. “It’s about honoring where Superman came from,” one defender wrote online.
Despite this, the majority of online reactions seem to align with the skeptics. “The costume feels like it belongs in the 1950s, not 2025,” one commenter wrote, while another stated, “It’s hard to take him seriously with that look—it diminishes the powerful image Cavill established.”
This divisive reaction to Superman’s wardrobe highlights the immense pressure on David Corenswet as he steps into a role laden with decades of expectations. Beyond the costume, the actor must contend with the inevitable comparisons to Henry Cavill, whose commanding portrayal and modernized look set a high bar for the character.
As the release of Superman: Legacy draws nearer, it remains to be seen whether the classic costume will win over critics or whether it will continue to be a point of contention. For now, the discussion underscores a larger challenge facing the film: balancing nostalgia with a fresh vision for the world’s most iconic superhero.
