James Gunn’s Superman, set to soar into theaters on July 11, 2025, has already generated significant buzz following early test screenings of its first cut. Industry insiders and select viewers who attended these screenings have praised the film’s potential to redefine the DC Universe (DCU), marking a bold new chapter after the uneven legacy of the DC Extended Universe (DCEU). According to reports from The Direct and ComicBook.com, the film, starring David Corenswet as Clark Kent, balances humor, heart, and epic action, drawing inspiration from Grant Morrison’s All-Star Superman. Beyond its promising reception, these screenings have also unveiled tantalizing hints about the DCU’s future, sparking excitement and speculation among fans on platforms like X.
The first cut, clocking in at approximately 140 minutes, has been described as a vibrant departure from Zack Snyder’s darker Man of Steel. The Direct reports that viewers lauded Corenswet’s earnest portrayal of Superman, capturing the character’s innate goodness while grappling with his Kryptonian heritage and human upbringing. Rachel Brosnahan’s Lois Lane reportedly steals scenes with her sharp wit, echoing her Marvelous Mrs. Maisel charisma, while Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor delivers a menacing yet nuanced performance as a billionaire mastermind. Early reactions, shared by insider Jeff Sneider, highlight Gunn’s ability to blend humor—initially a concern for some fans—with dramatic moments, akin to his work on The Suicide Squad. One viewer noted, “The jokey moments work within the edit’s flow, but it knows when to get serious,” suggesting a tonal balance that could resonate widely.

The film’s narrative, while not an origin story, dives into Clark’s life as a young Daily Planet reporter navigating a world skeptical of his old-fashioned values. Set photos from Cleveland, transformed into Metropolis, reveal a pivotal scene where Superman is arrested by figures like Rick Flag Sr. (Frank Grillo) and The Engineer (María Gabriela De Faría), possibly under Lex Luthor’s influence, hinting at a conflict with authority. The Direct also notes the presence of Ultraman, a rumored antagonist, and a massive Kaiju-like creature, suggesting high-stakes battles that test Superman’s resolve. The inclusion of Krypto the Super-Dog, who rescues a battered Superman in the trailer, has delighted fans, with X posts calling him “DC’s goodest boy.” These elements, combined with a battle-damaged Superman suit, indicate a story of vulnerability and growth, potentially culminating in a new suit symbolizing renewal.

Beyond the film itself, test screenings have offered glimpses into the DCU’s ambitious future. ComicBookMovie.com reports that the film plants seeds for interconnected projects, introducing established heroes like Guy Gardner’s Green Lantern (Nathan Fillion), Hawkgirl (Isabela Merced), and Mister Terrific (Edi Gathegi). The presence of Maxwell Lord, played by Sean Gunn, with his LordTech logos on hero suits, suggests a manipulative corporate force shaping the DCU’s Justice League International. Fans on X speculate that Lord’s agenda could lead to morally gray conflicts in future films like Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow, starring Milly Alcock, who may cameo as Kara Zor-El. The film’s ending, rumored to involve Clark revealing his identity to Lois and Jimmy Olsen, could set up personal stakes for sequels, per a Reddit leak from r/DCU_.

Warner Bros. executives Michael De Luca and Pam Abdy, speaking on the SmartLess podcast, expressed enthusiasm for the first cut, with De Luca stating, “Gunn really understood the assignment. His heart’s in the right place.” This confidence aligns with Gunn’s vision to honor Superman’s 1938 roots—truth, justice, and hope—while crafting a modern, cohesive universe. Variety notes that the DCU slate, dubbed “Gods and Monsters,” includes projects like a Batman and Robin film and a Green Lantern series, with Superman laying the groundwork for crossovers. However, mixed reactions from some screenings, as reported by X scooper MyTimeToShineHello, suggest minor tweaks may be needed, with Gunn confirming “tiny reshoots” to refine the film.
The film’s success is crucial, as it carries the weight of rebooting DC after the DCEU’s struggles. Forbes estimates a $700-750 million box office as the benchmark for an “unqualified success,” surpassing Man of Steel’s $668 million. With a reported $363.8 million budget (disputed by Gunn), the stakes are high, but positive early buzz and a John Murphy score evoking John Williams’ iconic theme fuel optimism. As Superman nears release, its blend of classic heroism and fresh storytelling could indeed make audiences look up again, setting a soaring precedent for DC’s cinematic future.