Should the Detroit Lions Trade for Kayvon Thibodeaux Instead of Drafting?

Detroit Lions’ Pass Rush Needs a Boost

As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the Detroit Lions find themselves at a crossroads. While many analysts believe that bolstering their pass rush is a top priority, the team has yet to make a significant addition through free agency. With options still available in the draft, some experts suggest that the Lions should consider an alternative approach—making a blockbuster trade for New York Giants pass rusher Kayvon Thibodeaux.

Aidan Hutchinson’s Impact and the Need for a Partner

Aidan Hutchinson has been a game-changer for the Lions’ defense. His dominant presence on the field, highlighted by a 95.0 pass-rush grade from Pro Football Focus (PFF), has significantly improved Detroit’s ability to generate pressure. However, outside of Hutchinson, the Lions have struggled to maintain a consistent pass rush, leaving a glaring hole on the defensive line.

“Needless to say, returning Hutch’s 95.0 PFF pass-rush grade to the lineup will have a massive impact on the entire unit’s ability to draw one-on-ones and generate pressure, something that was exceedingly difficult without him,” wrote PFF’s Mason Cameron. “However, the problem still persists: Outside of Hutchinson, this defense struggles to generate consistent pressure off the edge.”

Why Kayvon Thibodeaux is a Prime Target

Drafted just three spots behind Hutchinson in 2022, Kayvon Thibodeaux has shown flashes of brilliance in his three seasons with the Giants, racking up 21 career sacks. While he has yet to reach his full potential, his raw talent and athleticism make him a compelling trade target for the Lions.

Mason Cameron of PFF believes that the Giants might consider moving Thibodeaux to accelerate their rebuilding process rather than committing to his looming fifth-year option and potential long-term extension.

“With a fifth-year option decision looming – a subsequent extension – New York has a decision to make on what path forward to take with Thibodeaux,” Cameron wrote. “Should the Giants decide to maximize their trade value for Thibs, now would be the time. Detroit has the structure in place to tap into the pass rusher’s potential, as well as the cap space to facilitate an extension, should the team decide to.”

Trade vs. Draft: What’s the Better Move?

The Lions are in a strong position to draft an elite pass rusher, with prospects like James Pearce and Mykel Williams projected to be available when Detroit is on the clock. However, relying on a rookie comes with uncertainties, whereas Thibodeaux is a proven NFL talent with experience against professional competition.

Trading for Thibodeaux would provide immediate production and stability, potentially creating one of the most formidable pass-rushing duos in the league. On the other hand, drafting a young prospect would allow the Lions to develop a player on a rookie contract, providing long-term flexibility.

Final Verdict: Should the Lions Make the Deal?

Ultimately, the decision boils down to whether Detroit is willing to part with valuable draft capital in exchange for a more immediate impact player. If the Lions believe that Thibodeaux’s upside outweighs the potential of a rookie, pulling the trigger on a trade could be the move that elevates their defense to elite status. However, if they trust their scouting and development system, selecting a top pass rusher in the draft might be the smarter long-term play.

Either way, the Lions are in an exciting position to solidify their defensive front, ensuring they remain competitive in the upcoming season.