When Netflix’s adaptation of The Witcher first premiered in 2019, it quickly became a cultural phenomenon, drawing millions of viewers into the gritty, monster-filled world of Andrzej Sapkowski’s beloved fantasy series. At the heart of its success was Henry Cavill, whose portrayal of Geralt of Rivia, the stoic, silver-haired monster hunter, won over fans of both the books and the wildly popular video game series by CD Projekt Red. Cavill’s chiseled physique, commanding presence, and deep, gravelly voice seemed tailor-made for the role, earning him widespread praise as the definitive on-screen Geralt. Fast forward to 2025, and the announcement of Liam Hemsworth taking over the role has sparked a firestorm of debate, disappointment, and speculation. For many, this casting switch feels like the biggest downgrade in recent television history.

Cavill’s departure from The Witcher after its third season came as a shock to fans. The actor, a self-professed fan of the source material, had been a driving force behind the show’s authenticity. His dedication was evident in everything from his meticulous preparation—training for hours to nail the swordplay—to his vocal advocacy for staying true to Sapkowski’s vision. Rumors swirled about creative differences with the showrunners, with some suggesting Cavill grew frustrated with the series’ divergence from the books. Whatever the reason, his exit left a void that Netflix scrambled to fill, ultimately landing on Liam Hemsworth, known primarily for his role as Gale Hawthorne in The Hunger Games franchise.

On paper, Hemsworth isn’t an illogical choice. He’s a capable actor with a solid track record in action-heavy roles, and at 35, he’s close in age to Cavill, who was 36 when he began playing Geralt. Physically, Hemsworth has the build to wield a sword and the charisma to carry a leading role. Yet, the fan reaction has been overwhelmingly negative, with many arguing that he lacks the gravitas and intensity Cavill brought to the character. Social media platforms like X have been ablaze with memes and hot takes, some comparing the switch to replacing a Michelin-star meal with fast food. “Henry Cavill was Geralt,” one user wrote. “Liam Hemsworth is just a guy in a wig.”

Part of the backlash stems from Cavill’s near-mythic status among fans. His portrayal wasn’t just a performance—it was a love letter to the Witcher universe. He famously recounted playing the video games for hours, immersing himself in Geralt’s world long before the cameras rolled. That passion translated into a nuanced performance, balancing the character’s gruff exterior with subtle moments of vulnerability. Hemsworth, by contrast, doesn’t have the same public connection to the material. While he’s expressed excitement about stepping into the role, his past projects—mostly mainstream blockbusters—don’t suggest the same depth or familiarity with the dark, morally complex tone of The Witcher.

The show’s producers have defended the casting, with showrunner Lauren Schmidt Hissrich promising that Hemsworth will bring a “fresh energy” to the series. In a recent interview, she hinted at a narrative justification for the change, possibly tied to the multiverse elements teased in Season 3. Yet, this explanation has done little to quell skepticism. Fans point to Hemsworth’s lighter, more approachable on-screen persona as a mismatch for Geralt’s brooding cynicism. Where Cavill exuded a weathered, world-weary air, Hemsworth’s roles have leaned toward earnest heroism—think Gale or his turn in Independence Day: Resurgence. Can he convincingly growl “Hmm” and toss a coin to his witcher? The jury’s still out.

Production for Season 4 is underway as of April 2025, with Hemsworth spotted on set in a white wig and leather armor. Leaked photos have only fueled the debate, with some fans grudgingly admitting he looks the part, while others insist the magic is gone. The real test will come when the season drops, likely in late 2026. Until then, the Cavill-Hemsworth divide remains a lightning rod for discussion. For a series that thrives on its loyal fanbase, this transition risks alienating the very people who made it a hit. If Hemsworth can’t channel Geralt’s essence—or if the writing fails to support him—this could indeed go down as the biggest on-screen downgrade in memory. For now, fans can only wait, hope, and perhaps rewatch Cavill’s seasons with a bittersweet pang.