Superman, the Man of Steel, has been a cultural icon for over eight decades, soaring through comic books, TV screens, and movie theaters as a symbol of hope and justice. Yet, as the character prepares for his latest cinematic reboot with David Corenswet donning the cape in James Gunn’s upcoming Superman film, set for release in July 2025, a familiar debate has resurfaced: is the classic image of Superman—complete with those bright red pants—still suitable for today’s young audiences? For some, the costume’s retro design feels out of touch, especially when compared to the sleek, modernized look Henry Cavill brought to the role in the DC Extended Universe (DCEU). Corenswet’s outfit, revealed in early promotional images, has sparked controversy, reigniting discussions about what Superman should represent in 2025.

The red pants, or “trunks” as they’re often called, have been a staple of Superman’s design since his debut in 1938’s Action Comics #1. Inspired by the strongmen and circus performers of the era, the look—red briefs over blue tights, paired with a flowing cape—became synonymous with the character’s larger-than-life persona. For generations of kids, it was a costume that screamed heroism, instantly recognizable and undeniably bold. But as superhero films have evolved into gritty, high-stakes blockbusters, that old-school aesthetic has faced scrutiny. When Zack Snyder reimagined Superman for 2013’s Man of Steel, he ditched the trunks entirely, opting for a textured, armor-like suit in muted tones. Henry Cavill’s version was hailed as “cool” and contemporary, aligning with a cinematic landscape dominated by the dark realism of Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy and Marvel’s interconnected universe.

Now, with Gunn steering the DC Universe into a new era, the red trunks are back—and they’re divisive. Corenswet’s costume, unveiled in a set photo of him leaping into action, keeps the vibrant red, yellow, and blue color scheme but tweaks the design with a slightly looser fit and a return to the classic briefs-over-tights look. For some fans, it’s a nostalgic triumph, a nod to Superman’s roots that recaptures the character’s optimistic spirit. Others, however, see it as a step backward, a garish relic that clashes with modern sensibilities. “I can’t believe we’re still putting Superman in red underwear and calling it kid-friendly,” one critic posted on X. “Cavill’s suit was mature and badass—this feels like a cartoon.” The sentiment echoes a broader question: in an age where children are exposed to complex narratives and cutting-edge visuals, does a superhero prancing around in what looks like glorified swimwear still resonate?

Part of the controversy stems from how we perceive “appropriateness” for childhood today. Superman’s traditional costume was designed in a simpler time, when bold colors and clear-cut morality defined entertainment for kids. It wasn’t about realism—it was about imagination, about a hero who stood out in a crowd. But modern audiences, raised on CGI spectacles and morally ambiguous antiheroes, often expect more sophistication. Cavill’s suit, with its metallic sheen and lack of external trunks, felt grounded, almost militaristic, reflecting a world where heroes need to look battle-ready. Corenswet’s brighter, more theatrical design, by contrast, leans into whimsy, which some argue is exactly what kids need—a break from the cynicism that dominates so much of pop culture.

James Gunn has defended the choice, emphasizing that Superman should embody hope and accessibility. “This is a Superman for everyone,” he said in a recent interview. “The costume reflects his history and his heart—it’s not about being ‘cool’ in a brooding way, but about being a beacon.” Gunn’s vision aligns with his track record of blending humor and heart, as seen in Guardians of the Galaxy, but it’s a gamble. While the red pants may charm younger viewers with their playful energy, they risk alienating teens and adults who’ve grown accustomed to a more polished aesthetic. Early test screenings reportedly show a mixed response, with some praising the costume’s vibrancy and others calling it “dated.”

Ultimately, the debate over Corenswet’s look versus Cavill’s highlights a tension at Superman’s core: is he a timeless figure or one that must evolve with the times? For parents wondering if the red-pants Superman still fits into childhood, the answer might depend on what they want their kids to take away from him—unabashed idealism or a grounded sense of heroism. As Superman approaches its premiere, one thing is clear: those scarlet trunks aren’t just a fashion statement—they’re a lightning rod, forcing us to reconsider what makes the Man of Steel fly in 2025.