Henry Cavill, who captivated audiences as Geralt of Rivia in the first three seasons of The Witcher, has addressed Liam Hemsworth’s portrayal of the character in Season 4. Cavill, who departed the Netflix series citing creative differences with the production team, has made headlines with his candid remarks about the new Geralt’s appearance.

In a recent interview, Cavill was asked about the first-look images of Hemsworth as Geralt, which have drawn a mix of curiosity and critique from fans. Cavill did not hold back, commenting on Hemsworth’s seemingly “sweaty” look in the promotional materials. “Geralt is a rugged character, but there’s a difference between gritty and greasy,” Cavill said with a chuckle.

The former Superman star elaborated on his departure from the series, stating that disagreements over the show’s direction played a significant role in his exit. Cavill had reportedly been vocal about staying true to Andrzej Sapkowski’s books, while the show’s creative team leaned toward a more liberal interpretation. “I wanted to honor the spirit of the source material, but sometimes visions don’t align,” Cavill shared.

Fans have taken to social media to weigh in on Cavill’s remarks. Some agree with his sentiment, with one fan tweeting, “Henry Cavill IS Geralt. Liam Hemsworth looks like he just stepped out of a sauna. Not the Geralt we know.” Others, however, defended Hemsworth, suggesting that his portrayal deserves a chance. “Liam has big shoes to fill, but let’s not write him off before Season 4 airs,” another user posted.

Hemsworth has yet to respond to Cavill’s comments, but insiders close to the production have stated that the new actor has fully embraced the challenge of playing Geralt. Showrunner Lauren Schmidt Hissrich also defended Hemsworth’s portrayal, saying, “Every actor brings their own interpretation to a role. Liam’s Geralt will be different, but that’s part of the evolution of the character.”

Cavill’s departure and subsequent comments highlight the tension between the creative team and fans who loved his faithful approach to Geralt. His insistence on staying true to the lore resonated with viewers and made his departure all the more controversial. Hemsworth, stepping into this turbulent scenario, faces the daunting task of convincing audiences that his Geralt can live up to the expectations set by Cavill.

As the release of The Witcher Season 4 approaches, the debate surrounding the series’ direction and casting decisions shows no signs of slowing down. While Cavill’s shadow looms large, Hemsworth’s performance could either reignite fans’ passion for the show or reinforce the criticisms. Only time will reveal if the gamble pays off.

For now, Cavill’s remarks about Hemsworth’s “sweaty” appearance add another layer to the ongoing drama surrounding The Witcher. Fans remain divided, eagerly awaiting the new season to see how Geralt’s story unfolds with a new face—and whether Hemsworth can silence the doubters.