Every Wednesday, Taylor Swift fans scrutinize every detail on Travis Kelce and Jason Kelce’s podcast.

When the newest episode of New Heights aired on Wednesday, May 29, Swifties wasted no time in uncovering what they believed to be a subtle clue about Swift and Travis’ relationship status. In fact, some fans speculated that Jason hinted the couple might already be engaged or married. The Kelce brothers were addressing a Reddit “conspiracy theory” suggesting that Travis has a part in the upcoming Happy Gilmore sequel — which the Kansas City Chiefs tight end denied — when they began discussing their favorite Adam Sandler movie characters. Jason asked Travis which characters they resembled the most.

Travis answered for Jason, saying, “It’s either Bobby Boucher [from The Waterboy] or The Wedding Singer.”

Jason promptly told Travis that he “thought of The Wedding Singer for you,” giving the camera a serious look as Travis chuckled.

Fans quickly interpreted this as a sign that Jason knew more than he was revealing.