Kiké Hernández, the versatile utility man for the Los Angeles Dodgers, has long been a fan favorite at Dodger Stadium, known for his infectious energy, postseason heroics, and unwavering loyalty to the team. Despite his popularity and knack for delivering in clutch moments, manager Dave Roberts has frequently kept Hernández on the bench, sparking debates among fans who believe his skills and spirit warrant more playing time. Hernández’s deep connection to the Dodgers, combined with his unique ability to play multiple positions, has led to growing calls from the fanbase for Roberts to utilize him more prominently in the lineup.
Hernández, now in his ninth season with the Dodgers, has carved out a reputation as a player who thrives under pressure. His postseason résumé speaks volumes: a .278 batting average, 15 home runs, and 35 RBIs across 86 playoff games, including standout performances during the Dodgers’ World Series runs in 2020 and 2024. His ability to deliver in high-stakes moments, particularly against left-handed pitching, has made him a valuable asset. Off the field, Hernández’s vibrant personality and leadership in the clubhouse have endeared him to teammates and fans alike. Yet, despite these qualities, Hernández has often found himself in a platoon role or relegated to the bench, especially during the 2025 regular season.

This season, Hernández’s offensive numbers have been lackluster, with a .195 batting average, a .626 OPS, and eight home runs over 71 games. These struggles, coupled with a lingering left elbow injury that landed him on the 10-day injured list on July 7, 2025, have limited his playing time. The injury, sustained during an awkward slide into home plate against the Cleveland Guardians in late May, has proven more challenging than initially anticipated. Manager Dave Roberts recently revealed that Hernández underwent nonsurgical procedures to alleviate discomfort, but he remains in a “holding pattern” with no clear timeline for return. Despite these setbacks, Hernández’s versatility—having played six positions this season, excluding catcher—makes him a critical piece of the Dodgers’ roster, especially with other injuries plaguing the team.

Roberts’ decision to limit Hernández’s playing time, even before the injury, has been a point of contention. Fans argue that his defensive flexibility and postseason pedigree justify a more consistent role, particularly in a season where the Dodgers have faced offensive struggles and a depleted roster. The team’s recent skid—losing nine of their last 11 games as of late July 2025—has only amplified these calls. Supporters point to Hernández’s ability to spark the lineup, as seen in moments like his two-run homer against the Kansas City Royals in June, as evidence of his potential impact. Social media posts from fans, including one from @GrandSlamMLB on July 25, 2025, even claimed Hernández rejected lucrative offers from teams like the Tigers and Yankees to remain a “Dodgers legend,” highlighting his loyalty and fueling demands for more opportunities.
On the other hand, Roberts’ approach reflects the challenges of managing a star-studded roster. With players like Shohei Ohtani, Mookie Betts, and Freddie Freeman anchoring the lineup, finding consistent at-bats for a utility player like Hernández can be difficult. Roberts has emphasized the importance of getting key players healthy, noting that the Dodgers are not at full strength. He has also praised Hernández’s value, calling him a “Swiss Army knife” for his ability to fill multiple roles. However, Roberts’ cautious management—prioritizing rest and matchups—has led to Hernández starting primarily against left-handed pitchers, a strategy that has frustrated fans who see him as more than a platoon player.
The Dodgers’ fanbase, known for its passion, has been vocal about wanting Hernández back in the lineup, especially as the team pushes for a postseason berth. Comments on platforms like Dodgers Nation, such as one from a 64-year-old fan pleading to “please sign Kiké” for his priceless chemistry, underscore the emotional connection fans have with him. Hernández’s return from injury, expected sometime in August, could be a turning point. If he can regain his form, his presence could bolster the Dodgers’ chances in a tight NL West race, where they hold a 4.5-game lead over the San Diego Padres.
As the Dodgers navigate the final stretch of the 2025 season, the question remains whether Roberts will heed the fans’ calls and give Hernández a larger role. His loyalty, versatility, and postseason prowess make a compelling case, but only time will tell if he can reclaim a more prominent spot in the lineup and help lead the Dodgers to another championship.