The James Bond franchise, a cinematic juggernaut for over six decades, is no stranger to heated debates about its leading man. With Daniel Craig’s tenure as 007 concluding in 2021’s No Time to Die, the search for the next Bond has ignited a firestorm of speculation. The latest rumor, swirling across social media platforms like wildfire, suggests that British actor Aaron Pierre is a top contender to don the iconic tuxedo. Yet, whispers of dissent have emerged, with reports claiming Craig himself is boycotting Pierre’s potential casting. This controversy has set the internet ablaze, raising questions about the future of the franchise and its commitment to diversity.

Aaron Pierre, a 31-year-old rising star, has captivated audiences with his commanding performances in The Underground Railroad, Rebel Ridge, and Disney’s Mufasa: The Lion King. His recent role as John Stewart in HBO’s upcoming Lanterns series has further solidified his status as a Hollywood heavyweight. Industry insider Daniel Richtman recently leaked that Pierre is being considered for Bond, a claim that has sent betting odds into a frenzy and placed him alongside veterans like Aaron Taylor-Johnson and Henry Cavill. Fans have taken to platforms like X to praise Pierre’s physicality, charisma, and action-hero credentials, with many citing his standout performance in Rebel Ridge—a Netflix thriller boasting a 95% Rotten Tomatoes score—as proof he could redefine 007.

However, the rumor mill has taken a darker turn. Reports circulating online allege that Daniel Craig, whose gritty portrayal of Bond redefined the character for a modern audience, is opposing Pierre’s potential casting. The reasons remain murky, shrouded in speculation. Some sources suggest Craig believes the franchise should stick to a specific archetype for Bond, while others hint at creative disagreements with Amazon MGM Studios, which took over creative control from longtime producers Barbara Broccoli and Michael G. Wilson in 2022. Craig’s alleged boycott has sparked outrage among fans who see Pierre as a fresh, dynamic choice to usher in a new era for the franchise.

The idea of a Black actor playing James Bond is not new. Idris Elba was long a fan favorite, though his age and lack of interest ultimately ruled him out. Pierre, however, fits the bill perfectly: young, British, and capable of committing to a decade-long run, as reportedly desired by Amazon. The studio’s internal memo, leaked earlier this year, stated that Bond would remain male and British but left the door open for a non-white actor. This openness has fueled hope among fans who believe Pierre could break barriers as the first Black 007, bringing a fresh perspective to a character rooted in tradition.

Yet, the controversy surrounding Craig’s alleged stance has divided the Bond fandom. On one hand, supporters of Pierre argue that his casting would reflect the franchise’s evolution, aligning with a global audience’s demand for diversity. They point to his proven ability to carry intense, action-driven roles and his magnetic screen presence. On the other hand, detractors—some echoing Craig’s rumored sentiments—argue that Bond’s character should adhere to Ian Fleming’s original vision. This debate has spilled over into heated discussions on social media, with hashtags like #AaronPierre007 and #NextBond trending worldwide.

Amazon’s takeover of the Bond franchise has only intensified the scrutiny. With veteran producers David Heyman and Amy Pascal now steering the ship, the upcoming Bond 26 is poised to be a bold reboot. Rumors suggest a return to the lighthearted, gadget-filled adventures of earlier Bonds, moving away from Craig’s darker, introspective portrayal. Pierre’s potential casting could signal a seismic shift, but Craig’s reported opposition raises questions about how much influence the former Bond still wields. After all, Craig himself faced backlash when cast in 2005, only to win over skeptics with his raw, visceral performance in Casino Royale.

As the speculation swirls, one thing is clear: the next James Bond will face unprecedented pressure. Pierre’s supporters argue he has the talent, charisma, and star power to carry the franchise into the future. Yet, the shadow of Craig’s alleged boycott looms large, fueling debates about tradition versus progress. Will Pierre emerge as the next 007, or will another contender take the mantle? Only time will tell, but the conversation surrounding this iconic role is far from over. For now, fans eagerly await an official announcement, ready to see who will step into the gun barrel and claim the license to kill.