With Thunderbolts* set to hit theaters in just a few days, the Marvel Cinematic Universe is gearing up for its next chapter, yet fans remain fixated on the behind-the-scenes drama surrounding Captain America: Brave New World. Released on February 14, 2025, the film underwent extensive reshoots that reshaped its narrative and visual identity, sparking debates about what could have been. Among the most discussed changes was the transformation of Tim Blake Nelson’s character, Samuel Sterns, aka The Leader, whose appearance shifted dramatically from a comic-accurate design to a controversial final look. Recent behind-the-scenes photos from Blue Whale Studios have unveiled the original makeup design for The Leader, and the consensus among fans is clear: it was far superior.

The decision to overhaul Captain America: Brave New World came from Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige, who reportedly felt the initial cut needed significant refinement. The reshoots, conducted in Atlanta in mid-2024, introduced new action sequences and altered character arcs, including that of The Leader. In the comics, The Leader is known for his oversized cranium and green skin, a result of gamma radiation exposure that amplifies his intellect. Early promotional materials, including a Funko Pop and concept art, hinted at a faithful adaptation with a large head and vibrant green hue. However, the final film presented a different vision: a deformed, sympathy-evoking Sterns with a grotesque, brain-like skull, one glowing green eye, and a zombie-like visage. This shift aimed to emphasize his victimhood under Thaddeus Ross’s exploitation but strayed from the comics’ iconic mastermind aesthetic.

Blue Whale Studios, the team behind the original makeup design, shared their work on Instagram, offering fans a glimpse at what might have been. The photos showcase Tim Blake Nelson in a practical makeup application that captures the essence of the comic book Leader. With a pronounced, elongated cranium and sickly green skin, the design struck a balance between realism and comic fidelity. “The nature of filmmaking asks us to adapt—to respond with creativity rather than react with attachment,” the studio wrote. “We were originally brought on to design and apply the practical makeup for The Leader on the incomparable Tim Blake Nelson in Captain America: Brave New World. As often happens in film, the story evolved, and during reshoots, the creative direction shifted. Our version was ultimately not used in the final cut.”

Despite the change, Blue Whale Studios expressed pride in their creation. “Drawing inspiration from the original comic book art, we developed a look that felt both grounded and iconic—true to the source while achieving a refined, natural realism,” they noted. The makeup was designed to be lightweight and comfortable, a technical achievement credited to the team’s dedication. Sculptor Ernesto Cornejo crafted the look using a traditional clay sculpture, while makeup artist David Arherton applied it, working from a lifecast by Anthony Canonica Jr. Nelson himself had requested practical effects, wanting to feel the “weight of the deformation” to enhance his performance, a choice that aligned with the studio’s vision.

The fan reaction to these images has been one of frustration and admiration. Posts on X and Reddit, including comments from users like @MCU_Portal and @ItsNeon2401, lament the loss of the comic-accurate design, with many calling the original “so much better” than the final version’s “mutated” look. Critics argue that the reshoot design, with its bulging brain and grotesque features, leaned too heavily into horror, undermining The Leader’s calculating menace. While director Julius Onah defended the final look as a way to ground the character in the film’s political thriller tone, the consensus is that it failed to capture the villain’s comic book gravitas.

Captain America: Brave New World follows Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) as he navigates an international conspiracy involving President Thaddeus Ross (Harrison Ford), who transforms into the Red Hulk. The Leader, revealed as the mastermind, manipulates events from the shadows, but his screen time felt limited to some fans, despite Nelson’s compelling performance. The film grossed $415 million worldwide, a modest return compared to MCU heavyweights, reflecting its mixed reception. Blue Whale Studios’ unused design serves as a bittersweet reminder of a bolder vision—one that honored the comics while showcasing practical effects artistry. As fans look to the future of the MCU, the question lingers: could this Leader have elevated the film to greater heights?