The WWE Universe is buzzing with speculation following the dramatic events at WrestleMania 41, where Dominik Mysterio emerged as the new Intercontinental Champion in a chaotic Fatal Four-Way match. Mysterio’s victory over Bron Breakker, Penta, and his Judgment Day stablemate Finn Balor has sent shockwaves through the wrestling world, not only for the title change but also for the simmering tension it has exposed within The Judgment Day. With Finn Balor’s cryptic behavior and Dominik’s newfound spotlight, fans and analysts alike are questioning whether the Intercontinental Championship could be the catalyst for a full-blown implosion of their alliance.

The stage was set on Night 2 of WrestleMania 41 in Las Vegas, where Dominik Mysterio, often polarizing as one of WWE’s top heels, defied expectations. In a match filled with high-octane action, Mysterio capitalized on a pivotal moment when Balor delivered a Coup de Grâce to Breakker. Seizing the opportunity, Mysterio soared from the top rope with a Frog Splash, pinning Balor to claim his first singles title on the main roster. The crowd erupted, showering “Dirty Dom” with unexpected cheers, a stark contrast to the boos that have defined his career. However, the victory came at a cost: Balor’s visible frustration and reluctance during post-match celebrations hinted at deeper issues within The Judgment Day.

Reports from sources like Wrestling Inc. and Sportskeeda indicate that Balor was left “perplexed” and “furious” after the match, particularly due to the return of JD McDonagh, who aided Mysterio in his title defense on the following “WWE Raw.” McDonagh’s interference, alongside Carlito’s presence at ringside, ensured Mysterio’s successful defense against Penta, but Balor’s demeanor suggested he was not informed of McDonagh’s comeback. This lack of communication has fueled speculation that Balor feels sidelined within the faction he once led. Posts on X have echoed this sentiment, with fans noting Balor’s body language during a group hug with Morgan, Rodriguez, and Mysterio as a sign of his discontent.

Adding fuel to the fire, Mysterio’s post-match comments have raised eyebrows. In an interview with WWE’s Spanish media team, he suggested he thought he was pinning Breakker, not Balor, at WrestleMania. While some see this as an attempt to appease Balor, others view it as a calculated move to downplay the betrayal. Mysterio’s bold claim on social media, calling himself the “greatest Intercontinental Champion of all time,” has only intensified the narrative that he’s embracing his newfound status, potentially at the expense of his stablemates. Liv Morgan’s coy remarks about Balor’s “betrayal” during post-match interviews have further complicated the dynamic, leaving fans wondering if she and Mysterio are orchestrating a power shift within The Judgment Day.

The history between Balor and Mysterio adds layers to this unfolding drama. Balor, a former Intercontinental Champion, has been a mentor to Mysterio within the faction, but their relationship has shown cracks in recent months. Just weeks before WrestleMania, Balor publicly questioned Mysterio’s killer instinct, stating on “Raw” that Dominik lacked what it takes to be a champion. Mysterio’s victory, achieved by pinning Balor, directly contradicts that narrative, setting the stage for a potential feud. Wrestling veteran Vince Russo, quoted on Sportskeeda, argued that the Intercontinental Championship isn’t necessary for their rivalry, suggesting the personal stakes alone are enough to drive a compelling storyline.

The return of JD McDonagh could be the final straw. His unexpected alliance with Mysterio on “Raw” has left Balor isolated, with some speculating that Mysterio might be plotting to oust Balor from The Judgment Day entirely. Rumors of a returning star like Rusev joining the faction as Balor’s replacement, as reported by Sportskeeda, have only heightened the intrigue. Such a move would solidify Mysterio’s rise as a leader, but it risks alienating Balor, whose experience and fanbase make him a formidable adversary.

As “WWE Raw” continues to unfold, all eyes are on Balor’s next move. Will he confront Mysterio and demand answers, or is he quietly plotting retribution? The Intercontinental Championship, now in Mysterio’s hands, symbolizes more than just prestige—it’s a potential breaking point for The Judgment Day. With Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez also navigating their own setbacks after losing the Women’s Tag Team Championships, the faction’s unity hangs by a thread. The WWE Universe awaits the next chapter, eager to see whether Balor’s scheming will lead to reconciliation or an all-out war with his protégé.